While reading Saeed's analysis of the Qur'an, the section on ethico-legal teachings caught my eye. Saeed provides the reader with thorough descriptions of the five different types of teachings: obligatory, fundamental, protectional, implementational and instructional. These days, it can be quite difficult for every follower of Islam to follow these teachings. Due to the complexity of these teachings, when individuals do not follow certain types of teachings, have they jeopardized themselves for Judgement Day? Are there certain type of actions that can "replace" or "outweigh" others? Is there a concept similar to dharma/karma in Islam?
In opinion, when one follows a religion I believe there should be few mandatory duties to that follower, such as prayer. However, I do not believe one cannot practice a specific religion if he or she does not obey every rule/teaching. Is there a certain threshold of religious practice that promotes as a religious follower of a certain religion, or is it "the thought that counts"? While the "...Qur'an's main emphasis is on the relationship with His creation, rather than on providing detailed regulation for daily life," how much is an individual expected to follow the scriptures of the Qur'an to label him/her as a true follower of Islam?
I agree with your thoughts. My particular interpretation to my particular sect of Islam focuses on the importance intention and the spiritual aspect of faith, or the esoteric, rather than the physical duties that need to be performed. For example, yes, Muslims do not eat pork. But if you accidentally, or unknowingly, eat pork, are you immediately doomed to hell with no chance of redemption? The answer, I would say, is obviously no.
ReplyDeleteAnother way to think about it would be through the legal system: there is a specific distinction between manslaughter and murder, intention.
In answer to you question about "the thought that counts," I would say to a certain extent, yes. To be called a Muslim, technically, is to believe in Tawhid, the oneness of God, Nebhuah, the concept of Prophethood, and the Qur'an. By abiding by those outlines, one is technically a Muslim, regardless of their following of the 5 Pillars of Islam. It's important to remember that the 5 Pillars are not explicitly stated in the Qur'an. They were rather compiled during the Caliphate that followed the death of the Prophet.
Hope that helped!